Friend of the show John Patrick Coan guest-hosts this week as James was supposed to leave early and never does. We bring brothers Mark and Scott Piebenga on to discuss things they don’t want the other to know. We invent, not one, but two new sexual positions for adventurous Overshare listeners to try with their loved ones, and we ruin high fives for everyone.
James and Alex take some time to themselves to discuss Alex’s recent trip to his parent’s retirement home in the gayest part of Florida, where the social dynamics lead to some embarrassing assumptions. We also talk about the recent flood of pop culture news, including the cumulative outrage over lightsabers, black stormtroopers, and Jared Leto.
This year, Alex and James asked the Overshare family to gather around our table and share stories about the fattest holiday of the year. Kevin Gerrity, Zach Bartz, John Patrick Coan, Benji Orlansky (from Austin!), Courtney Crary, Tess Borgerding, Ali Barthwell and Rich Alfonso all bring their own dish to this potluck of scenes.
This episode marks the triumphant return of The Overshare’s reinging champion, Ali Barthwell! We also see the return of show favorite Buttercream Smoothe AKA Rich Alfonso. We play a card game called Slash, where you put two fictional characters together and argue for why they should fuck. We also discuss Interstellar and space travel.
Brian McGovern joins James and Alex this week to confabulate a few tales. Learn how it McDonald’s takes a turn when the McRib returns, and we offer some advice to a bridesmaid who is put in an uncomfortable position by the bride.
This week the Overshare has been possessed by the OVERSCARE! We bring you some of the scariest improv on the internet. Brian McGovern, Courtney Crary, Tess Borgerding, Kevin Gerrity, Zach Bartz, Nico Carter, Benji Orlansky, and John Patrick Coan take us on a trip to the dark side of improv comedy. Can the Overshare ever be the same?
This week Nico Carter and Brandon Shockney, two Overshare favorites, return to the show and bring it…twice! Due to a techical malfunction, we recorded two episodes this week, and one can be heard right here on Peaches and Hot Sauce. If you want to hear the other episode, you’ll need to find a way to plug your headphones into the aether.
Every important piece of pop-culture has a wedding episode, and we’re no different, just not important! Alex and James invite Courtney Crary and Tess Borgerding on the show this week to give a quick recap of the highs and lows of Alex and Courtney’s recent wedding day. We discuss how Alex almost got in his first street brawl while still in his tux, and James is frightened by a prowling bridesmaid.
This week James and Alex are very excited to have the enigmatic and eccentric founders and propreiters of the underground performing arts club known as The Shithole. Zach Bartz and Kevin Gerrity host one of the coolest shows in Chicago, and we ask them to overshare about post-marital sex, give advice to an adult man still under the influence of his girlfriend’s parents, and re-visit our Today I F*cked Up segment!
James and Alex at The Overshare proudly present the dumbest episode we’ve ever recorded. Joining us to bring you this 50 minute blooper of an episode are Benji Orlansky and John Patrick Coan. We probe reddit for some meaningful suggestions and immediately jump the rails and stay off them for a barn-burning 45 minutes. Don’t listen to this, but please listen to this.