Jessica Antes and Courtney Crary join us this week to find the strangler and the Thing who are hiding incognito among us. We learned how Jess got the nickname ‘Booty’, and the answer won’t surprise you!
This week Ali Barthwell returns to dole out some much needed relationship advice to a needy redditor, and Matt Pina joins Alex and James in judging Ali’s video game choices with much severity. We also check in on iconic host of Cheaters, Joey Del Greco.
Summer break is over for James and Alex, who return to the Overshare with a few more mosquito bites and a sun burn. We go to Reddit, who is always willing to overshare, and talk about a wedding decision that hits close to home. We also get too deep into a pyramid scheme involving murder.
Alex takes the week off giving Jamestime to sit down with Johnny O’Mara, Liz Anderson, and Patrick McDonald to discuss storms, sports, and spooky stuff. This episode is not for the faint of heart.
A Jonas Bonus from episode 79 features Patrick Bodenhausen telling James and Alex about his time about as a fake Jonas Brother! We do some scenes set in fake Hollywood making some fake movies, like National Treasure.
Patrick Bodenhausen and Spencer Hamilton join us this week to talk about our feminine sides. We recommend some products made for ladies that work just as well for guys, learn about Chicago’s laws regarding haunted double-decker busses, and we give some good advice to a man who lost his wife in a tragic threesome.
Laura Bloechl and Benji Orlansky join us this week to dole out some much needed relationship advice to some unfortunate redditors. We find out that marijauna doesn’t look like a used condom, that all husbands go to heaven, and we discuss wedding plans with two Long Island DJ’s.
Nancy Fast and Natalie Jones are in the James D’Amato’s One Shot Studio today to dish out some more much needed relationship advice to needy redditors. We discuss whether it’s okay for gay men to grope women without asking, and we find a stranger’s hair on our sweatshirt and freak out.
Today marks the first time in Overshare history that James and Alex are joined by…nobody. We celebrate ourselves this episode by giving some much needed backstory to The Overshare’s two enigmatic hosts. The wayback machine leaves us in highschool, where we see the humble origin stories of these two nerds. We also give advice to a woman whose boyfriend is pissed she won’t shave his intials into her pubes, so stick around for that.
Joining us this week for a roller coaster ride of emotions is Meghan Sullivan and John Patrick Coan! Coming off of an insane Cinco de Mayo party where James nearly died, we tell the story and use it for comedy, which we all knew would happen. We also hear about an ill-fated pinata, and meet a pretty cool principal.